Chapter 10
Types of Methamphetamine Users: An Attempt to Define Models
p. 143-159
Texte intégral
Ideal Types
1Every individual is unique, but individuals are also products of cultural and social environments. They adopt social routines and learn to respect rituals and codes that make their behaviour more predictable than it might appear to be at first glance. Therefore a single individual’s behaviour can be compared to that of many others. From the diversity of human actions, sociologists try to bring out patterns in individual behaviour that have an internal logic. With the help of a model, they attempt to impose order upon what appears as disorder.
2In the preceding chapters we have tried to give as realistic a description as possible of the consumption patterns of amphetamine-type stimulants in Thailand. This corpus of information now needs to be organised to create a model that can be used to both summarise the Thai situation and place it in broader perspective. We shall use a tool called the “ideal type”,1 the existence of which we owe to the sociologist Max Weber. The ideal type enables us to construct a composite profile of yaa baa users based on certain “characteristic traits”. Once arranged in chart form, these characteristics make possible an operative synthesis that can simplify reality without misrepresenting it. The procedure allows us to find order in the apparent disorder without deviating too significantly from the empirical given.
3The framework of our model consists of two variables that structure alternative yaa baa consumption patterns. The horizontal axis denoting stimulation differentiates two primary motivations for yaa baa consumption: that for recreational pleasure, and that for work. The vertical axis corresponds to consumers’ interest regarding their involvement with the yaa baa trade. Interest is negative for those whose consumption is a cost factor and positive for those deriving income from it. These intersecting axes yield four distinct situations corresponding to “strong profiles” of consumers and to “philosophies” of consumption. The four profiles by which all consumers are more or less distinguished include the regular consumer, the nocturnal consumer, the borderline consumer, and the expert consumer.
4A regular yaa baa consumer looks for stimulation to increase his physical capacity to resist fatigue. He may need this capacity to continue working, complete a task, or acquire knowledge. Whatever the pursuit, the ideal-type regular player finds himself in a race against the clock. Even if his income increases by the time the race is finished, the income thus derived is not obtained directly from yaa baa because the regular consumer is not involved in its trade. The regular consumer is in this sense a fighter who seeks to increase his perseverance against his enemy, the passage of time, to which the consumer’s productivity and efficiency are linked. Yaa baa is consumed by regular users for its stimulating capacity alone and can be replaced by a legal stimulant. The regular consumer is the only one who uses yaa baa in solitude.
5The nocturnal consumer uses yaa baa as a form of recreation for an evening’s entertainment with friends. Stimulation gained from its use is for no other motive than to enable the user to prolong a pleasurable situation. Time loses its value completely; the user can either be “caught up” or “lost” at will, depending on the orientation. Similarly, money poses no problems while under the influence — though it most likely will the following day. The cost of yaa baa is an expense the nocturnal consumer is quite willing to cover. His sense of belonging to the group gives meaning to his drug consumption, and serves to justify it.
6Yet under the cover of entertainment, the nocturnal consumer, through his act of consumption, participates in an encounter that is less routine than that of the regular consumer, but one no less competitive. The nocturnal consumer perpetually seeks opportunities for ostentatious display, and the methamphetamine tablet itself proves that he knows the “right way” to be fashionable. His consumption is more impulsive and occasional than regular. Yaa baa is a necessity, but for the nocturnal consumer its consumption is ritualistic as opposed to functional.
7The borderline consumer2 likewise seeks stimulation through drug consumption, but his means of doing so are generally less pleasure-focused and time-specific than those of the nocturnal consumer. Even if the borderline user’s practice is social, the drug-taking behaviour itself is motivated by the individual user’s psychological state that is troubled or anxious. The borderline consumer typically turns to yaa baa in difficult times, such as after losing a job or failing an examination. Under circumstances such as these, yaa baa comforts, consoles, and reassures. In the absence of alternatives, it dawns upon the borderline user that selling yaa baa would allow him to build up a small nest egg with minimal effort and finance his own consumption at little cost. Methamphetamine here plays a functional role by helping the user cope with adversity in daily life. Despite failure or troubles, he can maintain self-esteem. He needs the buoyant effect of yaa baa to retain a foothold in life and keep from sinking into a marginality that could bring about social stigmatisation.
8The borderline consumer is not yet a full-fledged expert in the underground world of yaa baa. He is still “on the margins”, occupying the boundary between legal and illegal livelihoods. The borderline consumer is an ideal type of neither-here-nor-there. Neither young nor old, neither employed nor unemployed, the choice between a legal existence and an illegal one is one that the borderline consumer has yet to make.
9As against this, the expert consumer has truly entered the world of trafficking and illegal activities. His passage into the underground economy renders him highly stigmatised and with few opportunities to return to a legitimate existence. This being the case, the expert accepts his marginality. He becomes a yaa baa professional wherein trade is his main source of income and his social network is restricted to other players in the underground system: friends, acquaintances, those who prescribe the drugs, and protectors. This is a dangerous position in Thailand since illegal trafficking can incur a sentence of capital punishment. To experience yaa baa under these circumstances is no longer a means of pleasure, but a tool for work-related stress management that comes with being a dealer, allowing the user to stay alert to the threats of vengeance, denunciation, and repression that characterise encounters in the underground drug world.
10These profiles are valid only for describing the essence of distinct behavioural patterns. They are pure constructions but as we will see, constructions that come to life when applied to the everyday realities and career paths of actual yaa baa users. Through first charting these concepts as they are actually lived, and then comparing them, we can obtain a dynamic table of methamphetamine consumption.
Comparing Ideal Types and Profiles of Actual Consumers
11A variety of consumers have profiles similar to the ideal typical regular consumer. They could be students who are playing it safe in their quest to pass exams, or peasants, drivers, labourers, or fishermen who push themselves to work harder in order to supplement their income. The regular yaa baa consumer is a worker who fears, above all, that the effects of fatigue could thwart his plans.
12The ideal typical nocturnal consumer resonates with the multitudes of young peer groups in contemporary Thai society who aspire only “to be together”, a companionship achieved through conversing, competing, quarrelling, or simply going out to a disco together.
13The ideal typical borderline consumer reflects the reality of those who live on “small jobs” between periods of employment and unemployment; homeless children too young to be real dealers and too poor to attend school, who “peddle” drugs; and refugees who take to prostitution and risk psychological and social decline in hopes of attaining a better standard of living.
14The borderline consumer is a decisive stage that can foreshadow passage into the underground economy. The full-fledged expert, on the other hand, has fully come to terms with his status of “trafficker”. Professional yaa baa dealers, retailers, distributors, and stockists, as well as government servants who benefit by supporting such illegal activities,3 are close to this ideal type. Their experience of yaa baa as users is intertwined with extremely lucrative trading activities.
15Thus, superimposing profiles of actual yaa baa consumers upon the ideal typical ones reveals three populations of users, namely, students, workers, and the poor.
A Dynamic Perspective
16If we can pin down ideal type profiles of yaa baa consumers at a single historical moment, then how might we begin to understand the development and interconnections of such profiles over time? It is difficult to speculate about long-term historical trends from what is in essence a ten-year-old phenomenon; the outcome of paths being tread by present-day yaa baa consumers in Thailand and elsewhere is still uncertain. Nevertheless, despite the absence of long-range historical data, we can transform this static chart of those involved with yaa baa into a more dynamic one through extrapolating from the limited data available and surmising from what we have already determined to be the main conceptual types. A dynamic table enables us to identify possible passages from one ideal type to another, and differentiate between those with “exits” and those without, between those who are condemned to continue with their consumption and those who are not.
17For instance, both the empirical data and the ideal type profiles acknowledge that a generational divide separates young consumers from the older ones — two user populations mostly unaware of the other’s existence. Old and young seldom interact except when both inhabit the world of the borderline consumer, a profile where the dividing line between generations tends to disappear. If we are trying to understand the development of particular careers among yaa baa users, then the data and ideal typical models that we already have would discourage us from assuming that a 45-year-old worker who today takes yaa baa to fight fatigue would have been a former “young” consumer of the drug.
18As a first step in constructing the dynamic chart, we can observe possible movements from one status to another. In Thailand a school-goer will aim to become a university student, failing which he will seek an existence outside of the university by cultivating ties with a close-knit peer group. In any case, if he is already using yaa baa while in school, his habit can continue as such afterwards. The only question is whether he will continue to do so under the auspices of a “stable” job or not, and if not, whether the alternative will be falling in with a group of unemployed or otherwise marginal persons who have become dealers.
19Young Thais who have finished school risk being tempted into becoming borderline yaa baa users. For them, as for people of more marginal social identities such as uneducated street children, prostitutes, refugees, or heroin addicts, the regularities of existence as a small-time dealer can seem appealing as such individuals face questions of what to do with their lives. The threat of unemployment, a prospect that many workers faced during periods such as the 1997 crisis in Southeast Asia, can also propel individuals who have jobs into drug-dealing activities of the borderline consumer.
20A player in the yaa baa trade who occupies the position of borderline consumer is caught in a current heading toward escalating levels of illegality. The borderline player has only partially mastered the codes of the illegal market. He straddles the intersection of the two systems, and his social and economic circumstances largely determine whether and how he will experience the passage from a semi-legitimate world to a fully-illegitimate one.
21At the borderline level, the consumer still has hope of one day exiting from the “yaa baa system”. But the longer he remains a borderline player, the more likely it becomes that he will have a long “career” in the underworld economy by ascending to an important position in the hierarchy of dealers and thus becoming a professional yaa baa trafficker. The eventuality of borderline individuals turning professional is all the more probable as Thailand’s methamphetamine economy continues to expand.
22Young school graduates and others on the margins of society are not the only populations prone to cross from borderline to professional involvement in the drug trade. Those in government administration are also vulnerable. If a corrupt official has compromised himself and risks being exposed, he has no alternative but to enter the “system” and place himself at the service of the professional yaa baa trade. Even if he can retain his administrative position by seeking protection from higher-level corrupt bureaucrats or elected officials, any career hopes must now be hitched to the underground economy; ahead of him lies the prospect of illegal trade of even larger proportions.
23The ease or difficulty of extricating oneself from yaa baa use depends on one’s position in the consumption chart. The motivation to quit can be created when, for instance, the user is somehow made aware of the danger of taking yaa baa. A colleague’s road accident, a university friend’s addiction or a parent’s warning are factors that can cause a truck driver, a college student or secondary school pupil to give up the habit. An exit is made all the easier if the user’s involvement with yaa baa reaps no financial rewards. Alternatively, foregoing involvement with yaa baa becomes difficult when its consumption is connected to the user’s direct economic dependence on its sale.
Scope and Limitations of the Model
Extrapolating the Model to Three Bordering Countries
24The preceding model is based on an analysis of the methamphetamine economy of Thailand. Admittedly, some aspects of it are speculative and not based on detailed research that would undoubtedly permit more concrete results. Nevertheless, the model provides a point of departure for further analysis of a phenomenon central not only to Thai society, but also to the surrounding areas of the Golden Triangle — and beyond — that play a key role in the production and distribution of the drug. Following is a preliminary effort to evaluate in what measure it is possible to apply the Thai model to Cambodia, Laos and Burma.
Cambodia
25During the late 1990s, Cambodian society experienced a significant increase in ATS consumption. This change was closely related to the expansion of yaa baa in Thailand, according to one observer, because methamphetamine was originally imported into Cambodia from there.4 However, trade flows of the drug were later partially reversed, with Cambodia becoming a producer for the Thai market. Given increased supplies of the drug for a foreign market, this naturally also led to an increase in local demand. As in Thailand, the expansion of the yaa baa trade in Cambodia extended to numerous sectors of the population, including students, “pleasure merchants”, and labourers, with significant numbers of the educated showing use as well.
26Jacques Vincent notes that in Phnom Penh we can currently observe the “gilded jackets”, that is, groups of youngsters coming from well-to-do families who swagger around Phnom Penh and are much more in evidence than before.5 But the nightclub culture associated with drug use in Thailand is far less common in Cambodia because of the virtual lack of any significant middle class there.
27Cambodia’s economy is in ruins. Only 20 per cent of the urban population and 12 per cent of the rural population has access to potable water.6 With a per capita income of less than 300 dollars per annum, and with nearly four out of ten people living below the poverty line, the country is one of the poorest nations in the world. The adult literacy rate is less than 40 per cent. Less than one out of two children completed a primary school education7 and it is likely that this proportion will decline even further as government funding for education continues to wane.
28Compared to Thailand, the yaa baa phenomenon in Cambodia emerges out of the general context of poverty, a social condition favouring the consumption of psychotropic drugs. For thousands of women there who work in brothels, injecting methamphetamine is now a favoured alternative to heroin. Heroin, a formerly popular drug, has now become too costly for many impoverished users. It would seem that a large proportion of Cambodian ATS consumers are of the borderline consumer ideal type rather than the pleasure-seeking nocturnal user, the latter of which accounts for a major share of Thai consumers.
29Methamphetamine is still a marginal phenomenon in Cambodia because the range of available and affordable drugs there is not limited to ATS variants alone. Other drugs, such as inhalants, are popular among both homeless children and villagers. One study indicates that more than 75 per cent of street children regularly sniff glue. Inhalants also face competition from other products, preferably those that can be injected. An example of the latter is “blackwater opium”,8 a muddy residue obtained during the process of extracting opium from poppies. Though considered a waste product, it is nevertheless said to produce effective results for the price. The popularity of substances such as these reveals the extreme poverty afflicting an increasing share of Cambodia’s population, a situation that continues to favour the rapid expansion of the market for stimulants.
30The pyramid-shaped diagram representing Cambodia’s population breakdown by age group reflects the heavy price that its inhabitants have had to pay for the war and subsequent auto-genocide during the Khmer Rouge regime (1975–9). Currently some 45 per cent of the population is between one to fourteen years old, and only three per cent of inhabitants are aged 65 years or older.9 For drug traffickers, such a youthful population represents an invaluable supply of potential consumers. According to one observer, the major drug problem now taking shape in Cambodia centres around methamphetamine. Major risk groups are no longer small cliques of marginalised persons disdained by society, but rather substantial populations of primary and secondary school children. Paradoxically, the fact that these children are generally too poor to afford drugs is the only thing that dissuades traffickers from making inroads into this huge potential market.
Burma
31Even the regional delegation of United Nations Drug Control Programme based in Rangoon admits that currently little is known about the state of amphetamine-type stimulants in Burma. According to a January 2000 government census, 31 per cent of 86,000 known drug consumers in the country were thought to be using heroin.10 However, this estimate was apparently obtained from projections using figures from 1974, and hence can hardly be said to accurately reflect the current situation.
32More credible sources from the World Health Organisation suggest that the total number of psychotropic substance users in Burma is nearer to 300,000. It is likely that heroin consumers would account for a large share of this number since they represented 98 per cent of the patients who received treatment at a medical centre in Rangoon. This assumption is all the more probable because heroin is very cheap in Burma, itself a heroin-producing country. Opium, which was common in the past, has been almost entirely supplanted by heroin. Nevertheless, locally-produced ATS pills are also available on the market in Burma, judging by recent major drug seizures.
33A 1995 study revealed unequal concentrations of drug-using zones in the country. Urban zones such as Rangoon, Mandalay, or Sagaing were more involved in the yaa baa trade than rural zones, except for the border regions of China, Laos, and the Shan or Kachin states in Thailand. Drug consumption in the latter areas is due to the presence of the mining industry there, where the seasonal workers employed depend heavily on stimulants.
34Recent journalistic sources confirm that jade mines such as Hpakant, to the west of Myitkyana, exploit thousands of Burmese in conditions of near-slavery. To survive these deplorably unsafe conditions, miners have no prospect other than to seek amelioration through heroin. Injections are taken every day with as many as 800 persons sharing the same syringe.11
35The principle of coerced labour established by the military junta is more widespread than ever, even if it is not acknowledged. It arises from the collectivist logic behind labour mobilization for national construction projects. In actual practice, Burmese who are forced to execute “public utility services” — which we can call “forced labour” — are in definite need of artificial stimulants to withstand the hard work and exhaustion.
36These consumers belong to the profile of the ideal typical regular consumer. For them stimulants provide considerable physical help and can assuage fatigue. In the absence of opium, workers who must toil under relentless conditions of forced labour rely on methamphetamine tablets. Compared to Thai workers, the regular Burmese user lacks significant control over his yaa baa consumption because he is obliged to take it as a part of his work, and receives it free of any direct cost.
Laos
37Methamphetamine made its first appearance in Laos only very recently. For a long time the country remained on the periphery of an issue that was central to the neighbouring countries of Burma and Thailand. Thailand took measures to safeguard its borders and waged a continuous battle to prevent transit of the drug through its territory. This caused traffickers to turn to Laos as an alternative. Traffickers were subjected to increasing repressive measures in the vicinity of the Bangkok port, formerly a much-favoured stopping place in the methamphetamine trade.12 They then looked for alternative routes through the neighbouring countries, particularly China, and also Laos, Cambodia, and Vietnam. In May 2002, Laotian police seized 120,000 pills along with one million fake 500-baht notes (12.5 euros).13
38Nevertheless the Laotian yaa baa trade remains epiphenomenal given current social and economic conditions there. The benefits of ATS for users in Laos are relatively few compared to conditions in Cambodia, where users are impoverished, or Burma, where they are subjects of an oppressive regime. David A. Feingold has observed that the economy in Laos was not as affected by the 1997 Asian financial crisis as Thailand because of the former country’s low level of involvement in the international financial system.14
39Laos is not wealthy, but its agricultural economy remains strong. Unlike many other neighbouring countries, Laos has not experienced a rural population exodus and thus its village social structures have been preserved. Given the lack of access to quality education — the literacy rate in Laos is among the lowest in the world — youngsters rarely experience difficulties integrating themselves into society after leaving school. In this respect they differ from their counterparts in Cambodia, where many children from the shantytowns of Phnom Penh have been rejected by their parents and left homeless. Neither are they like children in Thailand, who are often left to fend for themselves. Laotian families still need their children to work in the fields, and this factor helps socialise young people into the larger society. The social fabric of Laotian society remains close-knit, and any degree of methamphetamine use is subject to scrutiny from one’s immediate family, peers, and local authorities. Users whose consumption is excessive or indiscreet will quickly be stigmatised.
40On weekends, many young Laotians living on the banks of the Mekong River prefer to cross the river to attend a pop music concert in Thailand rather than stay in their villages and listen to traditional songs.15 It is likely that in doing so they discover yaa baa. But it is much more difficult for young Laotians to make the passage from casual to habitual user. Laotian youth are neither idle nor isolated. As victims of real poverty who lack access to even basic infrastructure facilities and suffer from an evident lack of education, the Laotian people are endowed with the most efficient weapon in the fight against the drug menace: social control.
41The model constructed to account for the yaa baa economy in Thailand is therefore not well-suited to the Laotian case. While a model for Laos would also need to distinguish urban from rural methamphetamine use, it appears that the relevance of the urban sector in the country declines in areas west of the Mekong, given current conditions there.
The Arrival of Ecstasy: A Social Distinction and a New Division
42At first glance it seems doubtful that a phenomenon such as the use of illicit drugs, which appears to be limited to particular subcultures of society, could possibly have implications for how society works as a whole. And yet this is indeed the case if we consider it part of the social process of distinction, an analysis developed by the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu. Bourdieu conceptualises society as a symbolic struggle for prestige and power between dominating and dominated classes. The weapons of this struggle are economic and cultural capital, and the objective to be achieved is “distinction”, in two senses of the term. The first is the capacity to determine symbolic differences between objects of consumption. The second is to differentiate oneself from others with regards to taste, judgement, and cultural capabilities.16 This social and cultural struggle for domination is essential for how a given society is established and maintained. Thus the two opposing parties — the distinguished on one side and the ordinary on the other — can only exist in relation to one another. It is their relationship that, even when contentious, gives meaning to cultural practices such as the consumption of illicit drugs.
43Illicit drug use is in fact not uncommon in this symbolic fight. Such practices enable some people to distinguish themselves from others and assert their superiority, which in turn provokes others to contest the first group’s claim to power and prestige.17 The struggle is generally turbulent, as the socially-recognised value of objects and behaviour undergoes continuous change. What was “in” yesterday is “out” today, when an item of consumption or a behaviour becomes commonplace.
44Until very recently, yaa baa was the only ATS available in the Thai market. The fact that the stimulant had long been used by ordinary people such as drivers and labourers gave it a reassuring image. Searching for new means of distinguishing themselves, elite youngsters who wanted to experiment with drugs had no other option but to try it. As we have seen, however, although yaa baa pills are of varying colours and shapes, these variations do not reflect actual differences in a standardised manufacturing
45process that could distinguish the product according to discriminating registers of price or effect. Thus methamphetamine carries little symbolic value in the distinction process and cannot in itself function as an element of social stratification. As a youth phenomenon, yaa baa has spread to young Thais en masse, without delineating concomitant social distinctions among its users.
46However, the unanimity with which Thai youth have taken to ATS has been shaken by the very recent appearance of a new product in the country — ecstasy. This psychotropic drug, imported from Europe, is sold at a much higher price than yaa baa and carries none of the latter’s mass appeal. Ecstasy is targeted exclusively at consumers belonging to the well-to-do class.
47Yaa “e”, the Thai name for ecstasy (pronounced with an “i” as in English) conveys an image of popular consumption as fashionable as Miu Miu apparel or Oakley eyeware.18 Local consumers do not believe this drug is dangerous because it is imported from the West. “My friends and I would never take yaa baa”, swears Yuri, 27, a young Bangkok photographer and ecstasy user. But does he mean he would never take it, or “never again”? He does not elaborate. But it is certain that claims about one substance being safer than another — as if ATS were produced under ISO norms of Afnor, the French association for standardisation — are very often used to justify a switch between types, for instance, moving to yaa “e” after having sampled yaa baa. Giving up yaa baa for ecstasy is most likely done to show that one has exclusive tastes and the means to afford them.
48Such displays are made possible by the relatively high visibility of ecstasy tablets on the nightclub scene in Thailand. In discos, imported yaa “e” has a more prominent reputation than that of local yaa baa. The drug acts to generate admiration from one’s peers as well as heighten the sense perceptions of the person who consumes it. Thus ecstasy is most popular among young individuals seeking recognition from the group.
49It is now possible to return to Bourdieu’s theory to place the above in perspective. The desire for distinction among those who use illicit drugs tends to make one substance obsolete in favour of another newer, more fashionable drug. Some observers think the arrival of ecstasy in Thailand could lead to a rapid decline in the market for yaa baa. If this is the case, the yaa baa “epidemic” may be nothing but a fad and so likely to die out.19 Whatever the case, individuals’ proclivity to use psychotropic drugs will never disappear altogether. One product simply drives out the other, a process that occurs in piecemeal fashion because it is largely the discriminating price of the drug deemed fashionable that makes it popular with consumers.
50The fact that young people in Thailand are constantly moving from one trend to another is indisputable. They might be shifting from one drug type to another, or one kind of social behaviour to another. Whatever the case, their ostensibly non-conformist actions reveal conformist preferences at work. It was not so long ago that opium was very much in vogue on Thai territory. When the government took measures to eradicate it, opium was replaced by heroin. Then, with the appearance of methamphetamine, consumption practices changed once again. Each time the preceding wave generates some residual users who remain attached to a product, but the overall movement between products continues.
51The formation of an “ecstasy elite” within the general market segmentation of psychotropic drugs points to new social class polarisation in Thailand. Referring to the organisation of Western societies, Alain Touraine suggests that vertical society — one’s position in a top-and-bottom structure of social classes — is giving way to horizontal society, or one’s placement in relation to the “fashionable centre” or the “unfashionable periphery”.20 Applying this conceptualisation to the Thai case yields organization that is both vertical and horizontal. One form is not giving way to another; rather, the society is a product of the cumulative effects of each.
52In Thailand, rank and status hierarchies continue to be important pillars of social structure. Simultaneously, young Thai’s adherence to a single fashion — the latest — represents a sense of belonging to a centre, a sole reference point. The horizontal organisation of Thai society is subject only to the disparity between city and countryside, which remains quite marked despite the mobility of the population. A young Thai now intensely experiences two worlds at once. He belongs to a rigidly-identified vertical class based on dominant and subordinate relations, and also aspires to the middle range of a horizontal axis of culture where extremes are considered negative and where an urban “modern” lifestyle is preferable to a rural “traditional” one.
53ATS is perfectly in keeping with this dual logic. Yaa baa has enabled one younger generation of Thais to distinguish itself from the rest along a vertical axis of rank and class. And if ATS has united this section of the population, the recent arrival of ecstasy shows that these products can also reinforce status-based social distinctions.
54However, the yaa baa pill, a product of “modern chemistry”, also symbolises the habits and fashions of the West for young Thais that can be measured along a horizontal axis of centre and periphery. Experiencing the effects of the drug, users have a feeling of participating in Life with a capital L, of having a hold on the world. As a perceived “global” product, methamphetamine is perfectly suited to a population that measures itself on a scale of global consumerist values. Yet this perception is ironic given that yaa maa, the antecedent of yaa baa, was first used by labourers in the country’s sugarcane fields — an irony that seems to be lost on members of Thailand’s current younger generation, whose ability to acknowledge their ties to the past is weak at best.
Notes de bas de page
1According to Max Weber, “the ideal type is a concept of reasoning, it is neither historical reality nor especially ‘authentic’ reality … [it has no other ambition than to be] a limited concept, purely ideal, on which we measure reality to clarify the empirical content of some of its important elements and with which we compare it”. The ideal type is a means of making data that has been collected intelligible by clarifying its consistencies and differences. For instance, in the following analysis, no single yaa baa consumer is precisely represented in one or in another of the described constructions. Weber arrives at his method by assembling data into types gleaned from a multitude of distinct phenomena that may occur in wide-ranging or subtle formations. Sometimes there is a wealth of examples upon which to base a given type, other times a lesser amount, and still other times none at all. Using one or several consistent viewpoints, Weber extrapolates from the actual or presumed phenomena to formulate types. Such concepts are then used to link the phenomena under study, and to eventually construct a homogeneous table of reasoning. Nowhere will we find the exact empirical reality that reflects all types represented in such a table, as they are purely conceptual. It is a utopia. [Max Weber, Essais sur la théorie de la science (Paris: Plon, 1992), p. 172.]
2According to Michel Crozier, Le phénomène bureaucratique (Paris: Seuil, 1963), “borderline consumer” is defined as the identity a player who positions himself at the intersection of diverse spheres of belonging. The term “surcodeur” (super-encoder) would also be appropriate here, following Lucien Sfez, Critique de la décision (Paris: Presse de la fondation nationale des sciences politiques, 1981). The “surcodeur” maintains thorough knowledge of the code of each of the social spheres that come into play. With one foot in and one foot out, in this respect the identity “surcodeur” corresponds to that of “borderline consumer”.
3There is scant evidence of methamphetamine use by government servants involved in its trafficking. However, it could plausibly be occurring, especially among policemen involved in the seizures.
4Peter Lunding, Cambodia Country Profile (United Nations Drug Control Programme, Regional Centre for East Asia and the Pacific, Report Number 1: 2001), see http://www.undcp.un.or.th/.
5Interview on 10 July 2001.
6The source for this and all statistics cited in the following discussion can be found in Peter Lunding, Cambodia Country Profile (United Nations Drug Control Programme, Regional Centre for East Asia and the Pacific, Report Number 1, 2001), see http://www.undcp.un.or.th/.
7Ibid., p. 10.
8Ibid., p. 17.
9Ibid., p. 8.
10United Nations Drug Control Programme (Burma Delegation), Burma Country Profile, see http://www.undcp.un.or.th/ [2001], updated site at http://www.unodc.org/pdf/myanmar/myanmar_country_profile_spf_2002.pdf.
11“A la source des pierres du paradis”, Courrier International, no. 585 (Jan. 2002): 17–23.
12Nualnoi Treerat et al., Global Study on Illegal Drugs, p. 100.
13The Nation, 31 May 2002.
14Feingold, “Sex, Drugs and the IMF”.
15“Le sauvetage d’une culture”, Courrier International, no. 571 (Oct. 2000): 11–7.
16Pierre Bourdieu, La Distinction (Paris: Edition de Minuit, 1979).
17“The Lure of Ecstasy”, Time Asia 156, no. 19 (Nov. 2000): 13.
18Ibid.
19Nualnoi Treerat et al., Global Study on Illegal Drugs, p. 13.
20Alain Touraine, “Face à l’exclusion”, in Citoyenneté et urbanité, ed. collectif (Paris: Esprit, Centre Georges Pompidou, 1991), pp. 165–73.
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence Licence OpenEdition Books. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.
Yaa Baa
Production, Traffic and Consumption of Methamphetamine in Mainland Southeast Asia
Pierre-Arnaud Chouvy et Joël Meissonnier
2004
The End of Innocence?
Indonesian Islam and the Temptations of Radicalism
Andrée Feillard et Rémy Madinier Wee Wong (trad.)
2011
Interactions with a Violent Past
Reading Post-Conflict Landscapes in Cambodia, Laos, and Vietnam
Vatthana Pholsena et Oliver Tappe (dir.)
2013