Abstract
p. 271-272
Texte intégral
1Though as yet unpublished, the site of Vouneuil-sous-Biard near Poitiers (Vienne) has yielded an exceptional collection of fragments of stucco from the excavations of 1984-1986. It has needed twenty years to bring to light not just the fragments already known about, but the entirety of the ensemble, revealing material of a quality well above normal and of an exceptional quantity. In fact, with nearly 2 500 fragments in terms of quantity it is well above the other groups discovered in France these last fifty years, be it at Saint-Denis, Bordeaux or Saint-Jean-de-Maurienne. Its study should allow the true significance of this exceptional ensemble to be appreciated, both from a regional point of view and in a wider perspective. As a result of undertaking these new analyses not only on the stuccos themselves but also on our knowledge of the site, with the assistance of one of the discoverers, it has proved possible to replace the ensemble in its archaeological context. It appears very unlikely that the stuccos came from the walls of the apse where they were found. In the light of the new project of geophysical survey, it now seems that the part of Vouneuil-sous-Biard studied here constituted but one element of an enormous villa.
2This rich ensemble should also afford the opportunity for a better understanding of the place of stucco in major decorative schemes of the post-classical period. It should be remembered that before recent work stucco, both as a technique and as a form of decoration, was for a long time poorly understood. The impression that it was only used both for plaster and for mouldings in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries long eclipsed its use in the Middle Ages. If E. E. Viollet-le-Duc and other authors did mention it, it was always in passing. Even after the work abroad of those such as E.L. Wadsworth or F. Berndt, in France it was not until the targeted research of M. Fixot of the CNRS that an interest in this form of decoration and its techniques was placed on a sound footing. This study will in particular make clear a continuity of techniques of manufacture in antiquity and will for the first time open up research paths into the Middle Ages. P. Deschamps, a specialist in sculpture, had only approached the question from the point of view of the history of forms, by demonstrating the presence of stucco in the early-medieval or the romanesque periods either in the texts or on some surviving structures. Researching Vouneuil-sous-Biard, has at the same time made possible the sampling of other sites for comparative purposes, laying the foundations for a national corpus of this material so often neglected or passed over by archaeologists or museum curators, and also benefiting from advances in the subject across Europe in recent decades. Several seminars and conferences, particularly in Italy and Germany, have reviewed these new approaches. The writings of Vitruvius on the art of building tell us that Roman stucco was manufactured from lime and not from plaster, and the study of the archaeological material confirms this statement. The creation of stuccos therefore used the same raw materials as mortar and coatings for walls : slaked lime and an aggregate. The main results from Vouneuil show that it was in this tradition of lime stuccos, and did not use wooden dowels or nails, but splinters of worked bone as also seen in the Roman stuccos of the region of Poitou-Charente. These keys, often necessary for high relief and cornices, were here used for human heads. Also in the Roman tradition, the surface of the stuccos was covered with a white render, sometimes painted. But more often it was reserved as white against a background of painted plaster, thus emphasising it and accentuating its moulding.
3In the body of material from Vouneuil, each piece of stucco has been treated as an archaeological artefact capable of yielding information on its making and on its place in the overall decorative scheme. Thanks to the drawings that have been undertaken the different stages of manufacture have been identified, not just for the stucco material itself but also of the painted material and the renderings. Likewise, the traces for fixing on the backs of the stuccos, elements for the fixing, the pieces with edges, have all given clues as to the techniques and means of the realisation of the work in three dimensions. It is from these indications and from the work relating to the iconography that it has been possible gradually to understand the positioning of the critical pieces, allowing the piecing-together of a massive, scattered jigsaw-puzzle. It has therefore been possible to propose a series of monumental arcades containing human figures and several registers of decoration.
4The dating hitherto given as pre-Carolingian, has now been superseded by an estimate based on other evidence (14C, the context of the site, iconography) that is two centuries earlier. This new estimate places the suite of stuccos from Vouneuil within what is often the missing link in the history of forms in Gaul, the end of late antiquity (end of the fifth to early sixth centuries). Alongside recent approaches to the sarcophagi of the South-West and other sculptural material, Vouneuil can now share in the creation of a new image for an era long characterised as ‘‘barbarian’’. The dates put forward on the basis of the most recent research for the sites in Ravenna, albeit still debated, demonstrate a continuity of production between the middle of the fifth century (with the construction of the Baptistery of the Orthodox) and the middle of the sixth century. The comparison with Ravenna seems to be required by the study of the iconography and the proposed dating. The stuccoers of Vouneuil-sous-Biard most probably knew the Ravenna work and doubtless other examples now lost from sites in between. This knowledge must have been transmitted graphically, which would explain certain simplifications or deformations of the vegetal motifs or the clothing. The monumentality inherited from the Roman period is demonstrated in our reconstructions and leads one to reflect on other major, lost sites known to have had extensive mural schemes, such as la Daurade in Toulouse and those that must have existed in the great basilicas of fifth- and sixth-century Gaul, to judge by the reports of Venantius Fortunatus or Gregory of Tours, for painted decoration at least.
5Lying between the Loire and the Gironde, Vouneuil-sous-Biard cannot have avoided an eventful political history in the fifth century, amongst other things because of the opposition of senatorial families and of bishops to the arianism of the Visigoths. With the victory of the Franks at Vouillé in 507, it perhaps seemed appropriate to reaffirm the orthodoxy of their faith through these monumental representations (prophets or apostles accompanied by the symbols of the lamb or the cross). With a reworking of its meaning in the eighth century, shortly before its loss, through the addition of inscriptions evoking various early martyrs, the stucco decorative scheme at Vouneuil-sous-Biard constitutes by its quantity, its quality, its date and the iconography displayed, a unique and very significant group for understanding the passage from antiquity to the early middle ages in Europe. It demonstrates continuity in traditions and represents a new stage in the history of forms and of pre-medieval societies.
6 Simon Esmonde-Cleary
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence Licence OpenEdition Books. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.
Les ensembles funéraires du Bronze final et de La Tène ancienne des Martres-d’Artière (Puy-de-Dôme)
Frédérique Blaizot, Bertrand Dousteyssier et Pierre-Yves Milcent (dir.)
2017
Le sanctuaire de Corent (Puy-de-Dôme, Auvergne)
Vestiges et rituels
Matthieu Poux et Matthieu Demierre (dir.)
2015
L’aqueduc de Vorgium, Carhaix (Finistère)
Contribution à l’étude des aqueducs romains
Eric Philippe, Bernard Lepretre et Alain Provost (dir.)
2013
