Chapter 12
Working Class Women
p. 171-177
Texte intégral
“[Ethiopian women’s] work never counted as work. Due to the low valuation and deliberate negligence of their labour, women were forced to believe that what they were doing would not count as work.”
Yeshi Habtemariam (1994, 59).
1Working class is a tricky concept. This is because it entails an objective component—a class as a group of people defined by the labour relations they are engaged in—as well as a subjective component—a class as a group of people aware of their mutual interests, bound by solidarity, and capable of acting in a coherent manner. For reasons of simplicity, and not to suggest the exclusion of any other category of workers, this chapter will focus on women engaged in a specific form of labour relations: wage-workers.
2Women have constituted a core component of the Ethiopian waged labour force since its emergence, contributing a majority of the workers engaged in some of the largest and most important sectors of the economy. Women have been consistently discriminated against, within the generally oppressive and exploitative conditions prevalent in the wage labour market, and even within some of the institutions of the workers’ movement, but they have nevertheless energetically struggled for their rights as working women.
1. Wage-working women
1.1 Taking up and giving up wage employment
3Throughout the past centuries, Ethiopian women have provided a large share of wage workers. In many cases, women have taken up wage labour because of economic compulsion. In other cases, pull factors such as the extra income generated have been the reason for women turning to wage labour. Although Ethiopian women’s labour has been devalued in general, the mere appearance of a concrete, payable wage made the direct value—often hidden within the household unit and agrarian relations—of female labour evident, and has thus provided a potential source of empowerment.
4However, Ethiopian women have often been expected to give up wage work when starting a family. For this reason, until the late 1970s at least, it was assumed that the majority of waged working women were either unmarried, separated or widowed. Although the situation was already evolving at that time, up to this day, a sizeable number of women still withdraw from the job market upon marrying or having children.
5More recently, labour migratory flows have resulted in a situation where many young women take up temporary employment while waiting for better-paid opportunities abroad. Because of low wages, other exit strategies from wage labour have also become increasingly attractive, including the prospect of engaging in self-employment and micro-entrepreneurial activities.
1.2 Main areas of wage work
6A major sector in which female wage labour was deployed early on is domestic work. From the first decades of the 20th century onwards, female servants in urban and semi-urban areas—many of them having migrated from surrounding rural areas—have often been employed and paid by the month. Since then, the number of waged domestic workers has multiplied with the increase in the urban population. In rural areas, it has been rarer for domestic work to be compensated with wages.
7Women’s work has, by no means, been confined to the household. In hotel and restaurant businesses for instance, female workers have consistently predominated, outnumbering males by a ratio of between three and four since the 1970s. Other forms of food production, including bakery businesses, have also provided an outlet for female labour.
8The development of a bureaucracy and of office work has opened up new opportunities for working women. They have become predominant in many categories of support staff. Over the decades, and with the expansion of education opportunities for women, they have taken over more and more professionally and technically demanding tasks originally reserved for men, and also joined the teaching profession in large numbers.
9Caregiving is another sector in which female labour has been important. In hospitals, nurses have tended to be women, while the better-paid and more prestigious occupations, like that of medical doctor, have remained, initially at least, in the realm of men.
10Many women have also been employed within the trade and transport sectors. Women worked as porters within large trading parties operating the long-distance trade routes of salt and other goods in the early 20th century. Such trade was eventually undermined by the coming of motor transport. But many women subsequently went to work in the offices and outlets of trading and transportation companies, though only rarely operating the vehicles. Although railway work was almost exclusively a male domain, air hostesses have exclusively been women.
11Another sector in which female workers have historically constituted and continue to constitute a majority is the important textile manufacturing sector. Together with food and beverages, since the early 1960s this sector has been one of the largest manufacturing sectors in Ethiopia, both in terms of output and employment.
12Women workers have also been employed on commercial farms and plantations, although male labour has generally dominated in this sector. However, in the horticultural subsector of commercial farming—buoyant since the early 2000s—around three-quarters of the workers are women.
13Women have thus provided the bedrock of what is arguably Ethiopia’s two most important waged commodity-producing sectors—textiles and horticulture—in addition to staffing a large part of the service sector.
14In none of these sectors, however, has the contribution of female labour been matched by representation in management, which has largely been a male affair. Although the situation may slowly be changing in this regard, male management remains the general rule, even in sectors where male workers are few.
2. Rights, conditions and pay
15Female wage workers have endured poor working conditions and low pay, which have been aggravated by gender discrimination. In this sense, it would not be an exaggeration to suggest—as Ethiopian radicals have in the past—that Ethiopian female wage workers have suffered from the double burden of class and gender oppression and exploitation
2.1 Pay
16In terms of pay, women have consistently been discriminated against. This is true whether one speaks of service, office, factory, or plantation work. One aspect of this is that women have occupied better-paid technical and managerial positions less frequently than men. But they have also been consistently paid less when performing comparable work. The result has been a persistent gender pay gap, which has varied only in degree over different historical periods.
17Until the 1960s, the gender pay gap within an institution was sometimes as wide as by a factor of three or four. But in later imperial times, several tendencies contributed to narrowing the gap. These included the expansion of education opportunities open to women, and the concomitant increase in the recruitment of women to qualified positions. During the first republican period, wage-levelling measures decreased to a significant degree, gender discrimination in terms of pay.
18Since there is no national data on the gender wage gap, the historical fluctuations are illustrated with an example from the Bahir Dar Textile Factory. The following chart shows the mean wage differential in a randomised sample of 800 workers from the factory. Whether the trends displayed hold true for other workplaces and sectors, and whether the indication of a recent re-emergence of a widening gap constitutes a general trend, is something that future research may look into.
2.2 Rights and conditions
19Until the 1963 Labour Law was passed, women workers enjoyed no codified labour rights. Even since then, the legal regime has displayed a consistent gender bias. At the most fundamental level, this has meant that none of the consecutive general labour laws has covered employment in the sector where the share of female employees is the highest: domestic work.
20But even women working in sectors that have been covered by labour legislation have found the laws and their enforcement insufficient. Poor employment security has been an issue that has persistently afflicted Ethiopian wage workers in general, and childbearing has frequently triggered women’s dismissal, despite legal stipulations. Even a high-end institution such as the national airline has been known to craft contracts in such a way that pregnancy may constitute a reason for termination of employment. For the workers employed in textile factories in the 1960s, or in small-scale bakeries where unionisation was not likely to be tolerated, the managerial prerogative in deciding such issues ruled even more supreme. Partly as a result of these factors, it has been claimed that women workers have been disproportionally affected by retrenchments. For example, those that followed deregulation and privatisation in the early 1990s.
21Workers being forced to engage in dangerous activities, lacking even the most basic protection and sanitation, and where there has been failure to enforce even minimum standards are other problems that have been rife in the Ethiopian waged labour market in general, and which have affected childbearing women preponderantly.
22But women workers have also been subjected to outright extrajudicial measures. In relatively new sectors too, old ills have reappeared. It has, for example, been documented, that female workers in the horticultural sector have been subjected to physical assault and sexual harassment.
3. Women in the labour movement
23Women have consistently been excluded from proportional representation in the higher reaches of the Ethiopian labour movement. Indeed, the election of women to the top position in the basic unions and federations has been rare even in the sectors dominated by women workers. This has, however, not prevented women from playing an enthusiastic role within the labour movement, and the idea that Ethiopian working women have tended to display relatively less class solidarity and militancy in confrontations with the management and the state has repeatedly been refuted in practice.
24Since the emergence of the trade union movement in the 1960s, women have constituted a large part of its membership and have actively participated in numerous strikes that have pushed the position of Ethiopian workers forward. Important strikes in the female-dominated textile industry alone have included the IndoEthiopian textile factory strike of 1961, the Dire Dawa cotton factory strikes of 1964 and 1968, the Debre Berhan wool factory strike of 1966, the Bahir Dar textile factory strikes of 1967, the Diabaco textile factory strikes of 1972 and 1973, the Barattolo textile strike of 1983, the National Textile Corporation strike of 1989, the Akaki textile factory strike of 1992, and numerous smaller wildcat strikes in the sector. In other words, predominantly women textile workers have constituted arguably the most consistently combative section of the Ethiopian working class altogether. In the horticultural sector, moreover, a number of wildcat strikes over the last decade has testified to the lingering militancy of Ethiopian female wage workers.
25Although women have consistently been severely underrepresented in the formal trade union leaderships, there have been prominent activists. Daro Negash, whose grisly murder at the hands of regime militia in 1977 constitutes an infamous crime, is one of them. She was a trade union leader at the Berhanena Selam Printing Press, with experience of leading strikes at the plant as a senior member in the militant labour opposition of the time. A detailed account of her case is found in an article published in 2019 by Jacob Wiebel and Samuel A. Admasie.
Conclusion
- Female participation in the Ethiopian waged labour force has consistently been crucial across many key waged sectors.
- As female work has been devalued in general, so has female waged work. A gender wage gap has been a consistent feature of the waged labour market, although it has been narrowed over time. Moreover, women have been subjected to extrajudicial discrimination, in addition to suffering from poor conditions prevalent within the waged sector in general.
- Despite having largely been excluded from its top representative layers, women workers have persistently constituted a core part of the Ethiopian labour movement, repeatedly engaging in militant practices and struggling for the betterment of their condition.
Bibliographie
Admasie, Samuel Andreas. 2018. “Dynamics of Assertive Labour Movementism in Ethiopia: Organized Labour, Unrest and Wages in a Socio-historical Perspective.” PhD diss., University of Basel & University of Pavia. https://edoc.unibas.ch/76747.
Bondestam, Lars. 1975. “Notes on Multinational Corporations in Ethiopia.” African Review 5, no. 4: 535–49. https://www.jstor.org/stable/45341395.
Hanan Aman. 2010. Action Research Report on Workers’ Conditions and Industrial Relations in the Ethiopia Horticulture Sectors. NFFPFATU/Study Report. Addis Ababa: National Federation of Farm Plantation Fishery Agro-Industry Trade Union, Women Working Worldwide Action Report, 2010. https://www.women-ww.org/_files/ugd/4111d6_794635ad23874e20afd5df5a54994dd2.pdf [archive].
Killion, Thomas. 1986. “Workers, Capital and the State in the Ethiopian Region.” PhD diss. Stanford University.
Pankhurst, Richard. 1968. Economic History of Ethiopia, 1800–1935. Addis Ababa: Haile Selassie I University Press.
Tarikwa. 1977. “YeSet Wezaderoch Tigil.” Addis Fana 2, no. 2.
Tewodros Worku Nigatu. 2010. Promoting Workers’ Right in the African Horticulture: Labour Condition in the Ethiopian Horticulture Industry. Addis Ababa: The National Federation of Farm, Plantation, Fishery & Agro-industry Trade Unions of Ethiopia/Women Working Worldwide Action Report, 2010. https://www.women-ww.org/_files/ugd/4111d6_f8cb6b349bbd494397ebd8aff532bffe.pdf [archive].
Triulzi, Gloria. 1973. “Women Factory Workers in Ethiopia.” In Leadership Development for Women, edited by Eva Zabolai-Csekme, 63–69. Geneva: International Labour Office (ILO).
UNECA. 1979. Women Textile Workers in Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: UNECA. https://hdl.handle.net/10855/5711.
Wiebel, Jacob, and Samuel A. Admasie. 2019. “Rethinking the Ethiopian Red Terror: Approaches to Political Violence in Revolutionary Ethiopia.” The Journal of African History 60, n°3: 457–75. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021853719000768; https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/output/1292850/rethinking-the-ethiopian-red-terror-approaches-to-political-violence-in-revolutionary-ethiopia.
Yeshi Habtemariam. 1994. “Ethiopian Women in the Period of Socialist Transformation.” Economic and
Auteur
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence Creative Commons - Attribution - Partage dans les Mêmes Conditions 4.0 International - CC BY-SA 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.
Educating the Nation in Ethiopia
State, Society and Identity in Wolaita (1941–1991)
Pierre Guidi Simon Dix (trad.)
2024